Luxembourg's MPs recently discussed the contentious EU initiative known as chat control, which entails automatic monitoring of communications on messenger services.
During the deliberations, all MPs underscored the necessity of combatting online child abuse. MP Ben Polidori of the Pirate Party, which had requested the debate, echoed this sentiment. However, Polidori highlighted the complexity of the issue, stating:
"To ensure the privacy of private chats, they must be encrypted. Without it, there's a risk of third-party intrusion, leading to potential theft of information, photos, or videos. Implementing message scanning presents two options: either devising a universal key to unlock message encryption or scanning messages before they are sent."
Polidori cautioned against both approaches, expressing concerns about the risks associated with granting universal access.
MP Carole Hartmann from the Democratic Party (DP) emphasised that this issue is at its core about fundamental rights:
"Data protection, privacy, and freedom of expression. This also means being free to share your messages, videos, and photos without them being monitored."
All MPs sought clarity on the government's stance. Minister of Justice Elisabeth Margue emphasised that the government remained sceptical:
"However, we appreciate the introduction of a more targeted approach. We have received the first part of a text addressing so-called 'detection orders,' and we are looking at this in detail."
Margue highlighted the government's objective to draft legislation that upholds fundamental rights while simultaneously protecting children and respecting individuals' privacy. The Minister of Justice also specified that she has a meeting next week with BeeSecure and the Children and Youth Helpline to further address these concerns.
