Appeal trialDefendants in Portuguese murder case maintain mutual accusations on appeal

Michèle Sinner
adapted for RTL Today
Nearly one year after being sentenced to life in prison for the 2021 murder of a man in Portugal, three Luxembourg-based Portuguese nationals faced each other again at the start of their appeal trial.
© RTL

The appeal in the high-profile murder case involving three Portuguese nationals living in Luxembourg began on Monday, almost a year after all three were sentenced to life in prison in Luxembourg for their roles in the killing of Ana's partner, Pedro, during a holiday in Portugal in 2021.

All names in this report by Michèle Sinner have been changed.

The court heard the same pattern as during the original trial: each of the accused continued to blame the others, accusing one another of lying. The accused are Ana, her mother Mariana, and Antonio, who was officially Mariana’s partner but unofficially also Ana’s lover. All were found guilty in the first trial of poisoning Ana’s official partner, Pedro, with an insecticide used against Colorado potato beetles, before pushing him into a river near Figueira da Foz.

Antonio declared to the appeal court judges that he is not guilty of what the others did, nor is he an accomplice.

Ana told the court that she is now doing better in prison than before, as she is no longer controlled by her mother and Antonio. She explained that she works, attends school, and makes her own decisions, seeking advice only from her lawyer or psychologist. Ana added that had she been the person she is today five years ago, she would have acted differently.

Ana apologised to her children and to Pedro’s family, recounting her version of events once again. According to Ana, her mother had repeatedly said that "if he were her husband, she would have killed him long ago”. Ana claimed it was Mariana who bought the poison together with a cousin, and Antonio who poured it into the glass, while Ana herself merely set the glasses on the table. Ana alleged that her mother then helped her move Pedro from the house to the car, and ultimately to push him into the river.

Mariana, Ana’s mother, denied all allegations, stating that "everything Ana says is a lie and that she is about to pay for a crime she did not commit". Mariana claimed that when she found out Pedro had died, she was too afraid to speak out because Antonio had threatened to take away her young granddaughter.

With each defendant offering a different version of events, the court faces significant difficulty establishing who actually put the poison into the glass. Both Mariana’s and Antonio’s defence lawyers highlighted the lack of material evidence and argued that it has not been proven that either of their clients planned the murder while in Luxembourg.

They requested acquittal for their clients on the charge of participating in criminal conspiracy (“association de malfaiteurs”), which would require evidence that they had conspired in Luxembourg well before the summer holiday when the murder was planned. If no such association existed, or if their clients were not involved, the court in Luxembourg may not be competent to judge what subsequently happened in Portugal.

Ana’s defence, meanwhile, asked for her sentence to be reduced from life imprisonment to a fixed-term sentence.

The appeal trial is scheduled to continue on Wednesday.

Back to Top
CIM LOGO