
Buying property off-plan, known as VEFA, has never been within everyone's reach, and even more so since interest rates began to rise. In recent years, however, it is not just the price of these off-plan properties that has come under scrutiny; the entire regulatory framework upon which such sales are based is now being called into question.
And for good reason: the situation of buyers can deteriorate very rapidly when a construction project fails to progress as planned – a reality RTL Infos explored in their recent series documenting real-life experiences from buyers.
Property lawyers Sevinc Guvence and Romain Bucci are very familiar with this type of case. In recent years, their firm has handled more than sixty similar matters, giving them a comprehensive overview of the existing legislation, the safeguards in place, and the challenges within the market.
And both reached the same conclusion very quickly: The legislation governing off-plan property sales is no longer suited to today's market.
This is hardly surprising, given that it dates back as far as 1976.

The two lawyers met with RTL Infos to discuss the major issues linked to VEFA purchases as they exist nowadays.
First of all, one must note that the government has been promising reforms to the VEFA law for years. Moreover, it was recently announced that the government would present a reform proposal regarding the completion guarantee before the end of the year.
It can therefore be inferred that the current system will remain in place for some time to come.
In Luxembourg, problems can arise as early as the initial negotiations between a buyer and an agent or developer.
Bucci explains that many real estate professionals are unaware of a legal provision that is, in fact, fundamental to off-plan property sales. "Documents are labelled as 'preliminary sales agreements', or 'compromis de vente'", which represent a "firm commitment" and include penalty clauses should either party decide to terminate the agreement.
However, the lawyer is adamant that "these agreements are strictly prohibited in off-plan sales (VEFA)". He emphasises that the standard practice should be a reservation contract, a type of contract that grants the buyer a right of first refusal.
"There is no firm and definitive obligation on one side to complete the construction and on the other to purchase the property. Unlike a standard preliminary sales agreement, it has no binding force", he clarifies.

Bucci also points out a recent Court of Appeal ruling on the matter, which confirmed that preliminary sales agreements do not apply to off-plan sales (VEFA). "There is fundamental confusion between a standard sale and an off-plan sale", he explains.
RTL asked him whether a contract could potentially be deemed invalid if a preliminary sales agreement has been signed for an off-plan sale.
The answer is yes. However, Bucci specifies that "only the buyer can raise this nullity".
This opens a door for those who may have hastily signed a preliminary sales agreement and wish to withdraw. However, it's crucial to intervene before the signing of the notarial deed, otherwise, it will be too late.
"We realised the extent of the issue when we started looking into it", explains Guvence.
It is important to clarify that the problems encountered in the Luxembourg real estate market are relatively recent. Indeed, in our reports on bankruptcies in off-plan sales, we were repeatedly told that the completion guarantee had never (or very rarely) been activated in Luxembourg before 2023.
This explains why the shortcomings of this mechanism have only recently come to light. Guvence was keen to clarify one point in this regard.
"Completion guarantees do not ensure the completion of the dwelling in case of difficulties", she says.
While this statement may seem counterintuitive, it is nonetheless true. Completion guarantees can be substituted as a reimbursement guarantee when this benefits the guarantor.
This is a significant issue because, in practice, the buyer has no say "if there is a material and legal impossibility of completing the construction", explains Bucci.
To put it simply, if a developer goes bankrupt after pouring the first slab, it is not in the guarantor's interest to try to finish the property. Instead, they will most likely opt for a refund of the work already completed, which will cost them considerably less.
In addition, the land share is not reimbursed.
"We only reimburse the value of the completed construction", explains Guvence.
Given land prices in Luxembourg, this poses a significant problem, especially for people buying an apartment in a complex. Buyers essentially become "co-owners of a hole in the ground".
Their chances of recovering their investment become virtually nil.

The situation is not much more favourable for someone who bought a house off-plan and is therefore the sole owner of the land.
In practice, they are often offered "crumbs" for land they paid a premium for. This is for the simple reason that developers know they are in difficulty and can therefore negotiate the price down.
The process of activating the completion guarantee is long and convoluted. "These processes are very difficult to implement, even for lawyers. There needs to be a statement of incompletion. To obtain this, the developer must agree to have the incompleteness officially recorded, which is rarely the case. Some require an expedited procedure, meaning an expert assessment."
Many aggrieved buyers would gladly avoid such a complex procedure, as it can last years when the buyer and guarantor are not in agreement. But for those who do make it through the process, it is important to know that overcharges are never covered.
This is a crucial point for anyone wanting to buy a property, but it is even more important that the contract be correctly drafted when it comes to VEFA sales. Indeed, reports produced over the last two months by RTL Infos have shown that several elements can cause problems.
In particular, the clauses concerning payment installments can cause issues.
The VEFA law is very clear on this point: payments must be made after the completion of the work, never before or even during the work.
RTL has seen many notarial deeds that were very vague on this matter, whereas the law is very clear on this subject. It is therefore important to carefully reread the notarial deed before signing it.
The two lawyers also point out that the notarised deed must include a specific deadline for the completion of the work. Therefore, a daily penalty clause must be stipulated in the contract for any delays, as this is not required by law.
This is precisely "where the case usually falls short when representing buyers, regarding the fixed penalty", Bucci notes.

Without this clause, buyers "have to provide proof of real and certain damages, and that can be complicated. Let me give you an example of a young adult making their first purchase, and the property isn't finished six months after the scheduled date. They still have their parents, but they've suffered a loss nonetheless. However, it's difficult to quantify."
Bucci explains that if the developer is a reputable professional, they will not object to the imposition of a daily penalty. "Except in cases of force majeure, they will honour their commitment."
Therefore, it should be considered a red flag if the developer refuses to include this clause in the contract.
Guvence urges buyers to be vigilant. "They often don't understand the implications of what they're signing", she laments. "If you have any questions or doubts, signing the deed is the time to discuss them. The notary is obligated to address your concerns."
Overbilling concerns invoices sent to buyers for work that was not carried out. Once these invoices have been paid, buyers will struggle to get that money back.
In the case of a refund guarantee, be aware that the guarantor is not obligated to reimburse you for these costs.
"The guarantor will tell you, 'Look, I won't pay for work that wasn't done'", Bucci explains.
This issue has cropped up multiple times in previous RTL reports, so buyers should always verify that the work has actually been completed before instructing their bank to make the payment.
The two lawyers believe that if the law is to be reformed, a mechanism should be introduced allowing for third-party verification of the completion of the work before the funds are released.
"France already has this system", says Guvence. Bucci highlights the benefits of such a mechanism for small developers, who would no longer have to chase after late payers.

In theory, this work could be carried out by a building expert or an architect at each stage of the project, but Guvence questions who would be responsible for paying these fears, expressing concerns they would be added to the sale price. The last thing this market needs is another rise in real estate prices.
"This is a problem that should be addressed before passing this law", she points out.
Other problems can arise when the bank acts as both lender and guarantor, which is common in Luxembourg.
"It intervenes at every level. On the one hand, the bank says, 'I'm not reimbursing anything because you paid for work that wasn't carried out'. But on the other hand, what does the buyer do when they receive an invoice? They send it to the bank. So it's the bank that releases the funds. This is proof that they don't check before paying", observes Guvence.
The lawyers believe the banks should be much more proactive in VEFA cases. Currently, they only intervene once a problem has already arisen.
But when it comes to reimbursing buyers, they scrutinise everything meticulously. Bucci questions why the banks don't monitor this during construction.
Luxembourg attorney Mario Di Stefano advised almost two years ago that buyers should always seek legal counsel before signing a VEFA contract.
The argument was clear: it will cost significantly less than buying from a dubious developer.
We asked the two lawyers what a lawyer will do if asked to assist with this process:
We would do several things. We would check the payment terms and the value of the land, which cannot exceed 10% of the total price, unless the developer justifies it. We would check where the bank guarantee comes from, and look into the status of the construction – is it already completed, or will it be completed? In the latter case, does the notarial deed include all the necessary documents? We would try to find out who the developer is by looking at their solvency, building permits, any appeals against this project, or any ongoing legal actions against this developer. We also need to know if you are signing a disguised preliminary sales agreement or a reservation contract.

Guvence points out that when dealing with a new developer, one that has only been in existence for a year, for example, "there is potentially a risk".
For Bucci, the choice is simple: "Even if it were to cost 10,000 euros, we advise paying it rather than embarking on a transaction that will result in much higher costs. Prevention is better than the cure."