Neo-Nazi gathering in WiltzNazi symbolism not punishable per se in Luxembourg

Claude Zeimetz
adapted for RTL Today
Recent reports of a neo-Nazi gathering in a Wiltz Scouts chalet prompted RTL to seek answers from lawyer Pol Urbany.
© Domingos Oliveira

After the revelations published by Dutch and Belgian reporters about alleged neo-Nazi meetings in Luxembourg in the context of Adolf Hitler's birthday in recent years, a number of questions have been raised.

How and why did the members of this so-called "Active Club", who outwardly disguise themselves as members of a fitness and martial arts group, but who are seen as experts in the far-right milieu, come to Luxembourg? And can they be criminally prosecuted for their behavior in Wiltz forest? What punishment does one risk in Luxembourg if one shouts "Heil Hitler", flies the Nazi flag and burns books?

RTL asked a lawyer to establish clarity.

In Luxembourg, incitement to hatred, on the basis of which a person could be convicted in this context, is regulated in Article 457-1 of the "Penal Code":

Art. 457-1

The law therefore provides for three conditions that must be met in order for a person to be punished for incitement to hatred in Luxembourg. The incitement must occur in public. It must be directed against people or groups and there must be a conscious intention to incite others to hatred.

Does the suspected neo-Nazi meeting in Wiltz meet these conditions?

Lawyer Pol Urbany says no. The people in the footage knowingly sought out a private place to remain amongst themselves and not be observed by the public. The incident was only made public because Belgian and Dutch reporters installed secret cameras on site.

In Luxembourg, it is not forbidden to fly a Nazi flag at one's home, nor to celebrate "Nazi parties". The law only applies to that which occurs in public, with the intention of causing damage or hatred towards others.

If "incitement to hate" is proven, one risks between 8 days and 2 years in prison and fines that can range from 251 to 25,000 euros.

Luxembourg's criminal law as strict as the Netherlands'

Urbany said the Luxembourgish and Dutch criminal laws are quite similar. One could ask whether the group from the two other Benelux countries deliberately came to Luxembourg to celebrate Adolf Hitler's birthday on 20 April, because things are allowed here that are not in the Netherlands, but Urbany says this is unlikely. He believes it is more likely that the foreign right-wing extremists sought out Luxembourg because they could fly under the radar more easily here and were not as known to the authorities.

Chalet owner not at fault

The owner of the Jitz Scout Chalet is not to be blamed. The Wiltz Scouts of the Saint Sébastien group, of the Luxembourg Guides and Scouts, could not have known who rented the chalet and even if they had, the law would not provide for any punishment. The local Scout group announced on Thursday that they had filed a complaint with the police after the revelations became public in this country.

Back to Top
CIM LOGO