Challenging outdated restrictionsHuman rights commission calls to end blood donation ban for gay men

Annick Goerens
The Consultative Human Rights Commission (CCDH) argues that the current blood donation rules discriminate against men who have sex with men, urging that individual risk be assessed for all donors rather than imposing a blanket ban based on sexual orientation.
The CCDH welcomes LSAP's new legislative proposal, which stipulates that no one may be excluded from donating blood based on their sexual orientation.
© Envato Seventyfourimages

For more than two decades, concerns have been raised about the discriminatory nature of blood donation rules in Luxembourg, yet no legislative action has been taken, according to Noémie Sadler, president of the Human Rights Commission (CCDH).

Currently, homosexual men are automatically excluded from donating blood for 12 months after their last sexual encounter with another man.

This exclusion applies regardless of whether the donor is in a stable, monogamous relationship or has multiple partners.

This restriction is not imposed on heterosexual donors.

Left to right: Bob Kieffer, Noémie Sadler, and Fabienne Rossler.
Left to right: Bob Kieffer, Noémie Sadler, and Fabienne Rossler.
© Annick Goerens

The CCDH highlights that the policy is outdated and rooted in public health strategies from the 1980s HIV/AIDS crisis.

Bob Kieffer, legal affairs expert for the commission, explains that today's medical advances, including near-universal, highly sensitive HIV testing, guarantee a much higher level of safety for both donors and recipients.

If the necessary waiting periods are observed, the risk of transmission is almost negligible and makes blanket bans increasingly difficult to justify.

Kieffer stresses that while the restrictions made sense in the context of the 1980s, current testing technology, and understanding of HIV mean the rules should evolve alongside scientific progress.

The commission believes the current situation fails to reflect these advances.

Assessing individual risk

The CCDH argues that instead of imposing bans based solely on sexual orientation, the focus should shift to individual risk assessment. This includes clarifying what constitutes "sexual risk behaviour" and updating the donor medical questionnaire accordingly.

For example, rather than asking only if a man has had sex with another man, questions could ask about specific behaviours such as engaging in anal intercourse or whether protection was used, which are questions relevant to both homosexual and heterosexual donors.

The commission has welcomed the 8738 legislative proposal from the Luxembourg Socialist Workers' Party (LSAP), which would prohibit the exclusion of blood donors based on their sexual orientation.

The CCDH supports the proposed law and calls for it to go further, recommending that factors such as gender expression, gender identity, and sexual characteristics also be considered to ensure a fair and modern approach to blood donation.

The commission also suggests that criteria such as donor age be reviewed. It notes that the government has already promised, in the coalition agreement, to reform blood donation policy and move towards an individual risk-based system.

Back to Top
CIM LOGO