Thousands of kilometres apart, two student movements have taken to the streets, and they appear to have little in common.
In France, lycéens et étudiants, school and university students, had mobilised more than 1,000 lycées by 2 October. They want Parcoursup, the national platform that allocates university places, scrapped or overhauled, and €10 billion invested in education.
In India, the Cockroach Janata Party began as a joke. In May, Chief Justice Surya Kant likened unemployed young people to cockroaches. Abhijeet Dipke, a political communications strategist, answered by launching a satirical party online on 16 May, its name a parody of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party. It gained millions of followers and became a street movement demanding accountability for exam leaks that forced more than two million students to resit their tests.
On the face of it, both these movements are drastically different. One concerns funding and selection, the other targets corruption and fairness. But beneath these demands lies a similar concern. Both are fighting against the mechanism that decides the future of young students.
In France it is Parcoursup rationing seats. In India it is a national examination board whose integrity collapsed.
In both, the state tells young people that success is a matter of individual effort, while itself controlling the door to success.
Governments increasingly preach individual responsibility to young students: study harder, compete more, acquire another qualification. But opportunity is not created by effort alone.
A French student can earn excellent grades and still lose out because there are not enough places available.
An Indian student can prepare for years but cannot stop a paper from leaking.
Yet when opportunities run short, blame still falls on the individual student.
Work harder.
Choose a different subject.
Acquire another degree.
What if the problem is not too little effort, but too little opportunity? And to make matters worse, the institution which promises a path to success is gatekeeping those opportunities.
This frustration becomes real when technology compounds it.
Generation Z did not invent frustration. Previous generations felt it too. What Generation Z has is a view of the world in their pockets. A French teenager and an Indian student can compare universities, salaries and prospects in real time. Sociologists call the resulting pain "relative deprivation": anger grows not from hardship alone, but from the distance between what you were promised and what you can see others have.
The same technology that exposes the gap also helps organise the response. The Cockroach Janata Party did not begin in a party office. It began as a meme.
The Convenient Condemnation
When student demonstrations disrupt public life, political attention quickly turns towards blocked roads, damaged infrastructure and confrontations with police.
Governments condemn the methods of protest. Public debate shifts towards law and order.
And the original grievances risk disappearing beneath images of burning vehicles and damaged buildings.
Violence cannot be justified simply because the underlying demands are legitimate. Destroying public property does not create university places or employment opportunities.
But condemning violence is considerably easier than examining why young people are protesting in the first place.
Both governments have taken steps to address immediate grievances. In France, Prime Minister Sébastien Lecornu announced that Parcoursup would be replaced in 2028. Meanwhile, India's protests ran about seven weeks before Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan resigned in July.
But these responses raise another uncomfortable question.
If governments can recognise institutional failures and announce reforms after thousands of students take to the streets, why did it take a breakdown of public order for governments to acknowledge what students had been telling them all along? Why not take corrective action in first place?
A damaged building can be repaired. A blocked road can be reopened. But how does a government repair the confidence of a generation that no longer trusts the system responsible for its future?
The generational reckoning is already visible in France and India. What began as protests over examinations, university places and educational resources may be pointing towards something much larger.
A generation that was told to prepare itself for the future is beginning to demand that governments prepare the future for them.
About the Author: Waqas M Awan is a Luxembourg-based corporate professional and the author of Power of Sage: An Anti-thesis to Machiavellian Prince. He holds an MBA and an LLM and has held senior finance roles at S&P 500 companies and Big4. He writes on economics, geopolitics, and power systems.