Chi-Chi Nwanoku (R) performs with the Chineke! Orchestra during a rehearsal at David Geffen Hall in New York on March 20, 2023 / © AFP
After more than three decades in the classical music industry, British double bassist Chi-chi Nwanoku began grappling with the question that had troubled her for years: Why was she consistently the only Black musician onstage?
"Why did I never ask anyone about it? Why did we never talk about it?" she describes wondering. "Was I being tolerated, or were people just completely unaware?"
"Or were people okay with the status quo?"
In 2015 Nwanoku took a leading role in creating a more diverse future for classical music, which, from musicians to conductors to repertoire, traditionally skews heavily white.
Principal clarinetist Anthony McGill of the New York Philharmonic performs with Chineke! during a rehearsal at New York's David Geffen Hall on March 20, 2023 / © AFP
She founded Chineke!, Europe's first majority Black and ethnically diverse professional orchestra, which this week played at the prestigious New York Philharmonic's David Geffen Hall in Manhattan's Lincoln Center.
The performance was part of their long-awaited North American debut tour -- it was among the many performances the pandemic pushed back -- which included stops in New York, Ottawa, Toronto, Boston, Worcester and Ann Arbor.
The New York show featured the pioneering composer Florence Price's Symphony No. 1, along with a rendition of Mozart's Clarinet Concerto featuring the New York Phil's principal clarinet Anthony McGill.
- 'Door-opener' -
Chi-Chi Nwanoku founded Chineke! Orchestra -- Europe's first majority Black orchestra -- to expand professional opportunities for people of color in classical music / © AFP
The London-headquartered Chineke! echoes similar efforts in the United States, including the Detroit-based Sphinx organization that promotes representation of Black and Latino artists in classical music.
Yet the League of American Orchestras, which represents professional and amateur symphonies across the United States, found in a 2014 study on diversity that just 1.4 percent of orchestra musicians were Black -- and there's little reason to believe much has changed.
"Because the great majority of American orchestras are not individually transparent with racial and ethnic data on their artists, we do not know the percentage of Black orchestral artists in our orchestras today," writes the Black Orchestral Network, a collective of Black musicians from more than 40 orchestras launched in 2022.
The Chineke! Orchestra is on its debut North American tour, featuring works by undersung but pioneering Black composers / © AFP
"From our vantage point, however, we have seen little meaningful progress."
It's mind-boggling to Nwanoku, who told AFP during a rehearsal break that "it seems to me that the only colleagues of color that I see who have a job in an orchestra in this country are those who are exceptional."
"We have to be that much better to actually be given a job."
Nwanoku believes that especially for young people, seeing more diverse faces onstage is "an immediate door-opener."
Members of the Chineke! Orchestra perform during a rehearsal at David Geffen Hall ahead of their New York debut in partnership with the Phil / © AFP
"It's the most incredibly winning thing to feel represented on a stage," she said. "Even if when you walk through the front of house to buy a ticket, if you don't see anyone who looks like you, that is immediately uncomfortable."
"But when you see people that look like you in any place -- in the supermarket, at the train station, at the concert hall, at the cinema -- you immediately feel that is a place that I can walk into with confidence," Nwanoku continued.
"You can be what you can see."